Tax receipts: Rachel Reeves "should hand back the cash" from her bumper haul

Rachel Reeves, Chancellor, is applauding higher-than-anticipated tax receipts

However, what is the source of the funds?

The news about tax receipts was better than what we usually hear. January's data appeared to be much better than anticipated after several months of borrowing figures rising steadily and the gilts market becoming increasingly uneasy.

HMRC always has a bumper four weeks in the first month of the year because capital gains tax (CGT) and self-assessed tax are due. January 2026 was better than normal despite this.

Last month, the government accumulated a surplus of just over £30 billion, which is more than twice as much as the £15 billion in January 2025.

Check out six complimentary BFIA issues now.

Gain unmatched financial knowledge, analysis, and professional advice that will benefit you.

Start your trial. This does not imply that Britain is suddenly profitable. To keep the nation afloat, we will still need to borrow over £100 billion by the end of the year.

However, the gilts market will be reassured and Chancellor Rachel Reeves will have a little more money to work with. The IMF will not be arriving at Heathrow in the near future.

However, this government's belief that merely extracting more and more tax revenue from a stagnant economy is a measure of success is exemplified by prominent figures like pensions minister Torsten Bell.

The expansion of the economy, the rise in earnings and profits, or the expansion of retail sales are not the reasons why tax receipts are increasing. The state is simply taking a larger and larger portion of the pie, leaving less for everyone else.

As soon as you begin to drill down into the figures, that becomes painfully obvious. The largest increase was in CGT receipts, which came from the sale of assets and totaled 17 billion, a 69 percent year-over-year increase and 1 point 1 billion more than the Office for Budget Responsibility had predicted.

Both employers' national insurance and self-employed people's self-assessment contributions were significantly higher than they were the previous year, and the yield from income tax has been rising due to frozen thresholds. It is easy to understand why revenues are rising when you add them all up.

There's little doubt that Labour backbenchers will be considering how to use the funds. There may be another pay increase for junior doctors and train drivers. It is possible to increase welfare benefits. The government is able to distribute more freebies. Modern windmills are available for Ed Miliband to purchase.

Labour politicians don't require much encouragement when it comes to spending money. Reeves will find it more difficult to inform them that the money is unavailable because it is the one thing they excel at.

Nonetheless, there are two significant issues. First off, the enormous increase in CGT receipts is not likely to continue. Investors hurried to sell assets, landlords to sell their properties, and entrepreneurs to sell their businesses due to all the rumors surrounding an increase in the rate in the previous budget. However, you can only sell assets once, and the total will undoubtedly decline significantly the following year.

Even though there is a slight increase in tax revenue, the fact that investors are abandoning British shares and companies at a record rate is hardly promising for growth.

Too many taxes are being collected by the state.

More significantly, it indicates that the state is collecting excessive taxes.

Reeves' massive tax increases are severely hurting the economy. The significant increase in employers in Northern Ireland may generate revenue, but it has also resulted in job destruction, with unemployment rising above 5% and vacancies falling to all-time lows.

With marginal rates of 60 percent or higher when accounting for student loans and tapered reliefs, frozen income tax thresholds are eliminating incentives.

If people would rather work fewer hours and decline promotions than accept such high compensation, that is hardly shocking.

In a similar vein, independent contractors are currently paying higher taxes. The number of people working for themselves has already decreased from a peak of more than five million at the beginning of the decade to 4.3 million now, but there are already concerning indications that many of them are working fewer hours or retiring early rather than paying punitive tax rates.

The tax haul indicates that the chancellor should use the Spring Statement to return some of the money since she has raised taxes too much.

A 30 billion round of tax cuts funded by the January surplus would significantly boost the economy and undo some of the harm caused over the previous 18 months.