What is the value of a lifetime ISA? The main guidelines and operation of LISAs

We examine the benefits and drawbacks of a Lifetime ISA, including what it is and how much the government bonus could increase your savings

Are LISAs beneficial?

A Lifetime ISA (LISA) can be a good choice for you if you want to move up the housing ladder but are having trouble saving for a down payment on a mortgage.

Although there are many different kinds of ISAs, LISAs are designed especially for people who want to save for retirement or purchase their first home. Savers find the account appealing due to its tax wrapper and the substantial government bonus it offers.

Over 1 in 5 million people have saved money in the LISA, making it a well-liked savings option. According to data from Hargreaves Lansdown, it had a record-breaking year in 2024 - 2025, in which 24% more people paid into accounts on the platform.

It is important to consider certain restrictions prior to opening a LISA. A 25 percent penalty could be imposed on those who disregard the withdrawal terms and conditions, which could negatively impact many savers.

After launching a review of the Lifetime ISA in January 2025, the Treasury Committee, a cross-party group of MPs, is now reviewing the rules. Nevertheless, recent remarks made by Treasury Economic Secretary Emma Reynolds have dashed expectations that the withdrawal penalty might be lowered or eliminated. The review is still ongoing.

According to Rachel Vahey, head of public policy at AJ Bell, "most people don't intend to make unauthorized withdrawals, but they end up doing so because life doesn't always go as planned."

Although they frequently would have, they haven't been able to avoid the charge. "We shouldn't penalize these investors because their plans have changed and they don't have the financial flexibility to adjust," she continued.

We investigate whether the Lifetime ISA is worthwhile and how it operates.

How does the Lifetime ISA operate?

The Lifetime ISA is a tax-efficient way to save money because all interest and investment gains are tax-free, just like all other ISAs.

You also receive a 25 percent government bonus of up to £1,000 per tax year, which is the LISA's special selling point. For instance, if you deposit £2,000 into your LISA during a tax year, you will receive a £500 top-up; if you deposit £4,000, you will receive the entire £1,000.

You have to be between the ages of 18 and 39 to open one. After that, you can contribute up to £4,000 annually until you reach 50. This amount goes toward your yearly ISA cap, which is £20,000 for the 2025 - 2026 tax year. You can keep cash or stocks and shares in a LISA, just like in adult and junior ISAs.

A first home worth up to £450,000 can be purchased with the money you accumulate. Alternatively, you can use the funds later in life, as withdrawals are allowed without penalties after the age of 60. If you have less than 12 months to live and are terminally ill, you can also access the account without paying any fees.

However, you will be penalized for withdrawing for any other reason, as we have previously implemented. It costs 25% of your pot as an exit fee. This not only effectively deducts the government bonus, but it also depletes some of your personal funds.

Your government bonus, for instance, would increase your pot balance from 10,000 to 12,500. Since 25% of 12,500 is 3,125, an unauthorized withdrawal would result in the loss of both the bonus and 625 of your personal savings. Thus, the 10,000 pot you started with would now be 9,375.

If you attempt to use the money on a property that costs more than £450,000, you will also be charged an exit fee. Laura Suter, head of personal finance at AJ Bell, states that "anyone who exceeds the 450,000 limit, even by just 1 will be hit with the 25 percent exit charge on the Lifetime ISA, as their purchase will no longer be within the rules."

During the coronavirus pandemic, the exit fee was lowered to 20% due to public outcry over its unfairness; however, in April 2021, it was raised back to 25%.

Where are LISAs being used?

Only a small number of people are currently benefited by the LISA, despite its widespread use. According to recent correspondence from HMRC that Quilter was able to access, only 228,000 people have been able to use their LISA savings.

This has been especially bad for London. Only 18,350 individuals in the area have utilized their LISA to assist in the purchase of their first home since 2018, according to Quilter. This amounts to a mere 0.56% of all first-time buyers between the ages of 18 and 40.

This is probably due to the contentious 450,000 house price cap being too low for the London real estate market, where, according to HM Land Registry data, the average home costs an outrageous 556,000.

While usage has been lower in London, it has been higher in other parts of the United Kingdom. With 38,650 people using the savings vehicle to assist with their first home purchase, the South East had the largest number of LISA users.

Because the North West had the second-highest rate of LISA use27,900 people used their government-boosted savings to purchase their first homehomebuyers there were also big fans of the program.

In contrast, only 7,650 people in the North East used a LISA to assist in the purchase of a home, making them the least likely to do so in the region.

Why do people dislike the Lifetime ISA rules?

The 450,000 house price cap is regarded as antiquated, which is one of the several reasons why experts have been advocating for LISA reforms.

Official statistics from HM Land Registry show that the average price of a home in the UK was 220,000 at the time the Lifetime ISA was introduced. Currently, average prices have increased by 22% to 268,000. The considerable price increase has never been reflected in an update to the LISA limit.

Additionally, there is a sense of unfairness brought about by regional differences in home prices.

Using a LISA to move up the housing ladder would be most difficult for people in southern England, according to official data.

While typical London prices (556,000) are probably completely out of reach, average prices in the South East (385,000) and East of England (338,000) are near the limit.

Those who live in these areas may be further penalized by the LISA exit fine after already struggling to climb the housing ladder due to exorbitant prices.

What is the Lifetime ISA review?

The LISA rules, which were previously introduced, are presently being reviewed. Earlier this year, a cross-party group of MPs called for evidence from the Treasury Committee.

The group has been looking for opinions from experts, consumers, and people in the financial sector. Among other things, attention has been paid to the house price cap and the 25% withdrawal penalty. Finding out if the LISA is still appropriate nine years after it was first proposed is the goal.

During her testimony at the committee's inquiry in April, Emma Reynolds, the Treasury's economic secretary, dashed hopes for reforms to the withdrawal penalty.

"The LISA is a voluntary savings product, but neither I nor we designed it. "People approach it with open minds," Reynolds remarked.

"A product like this must have a penalty or withdrawal fee; we cannot have a risk-free option where you are investing for the long term but there is no charge if you take it out.

It is still being reviewed.

Is it still worthwhile to get the Lifetime ISA?

On top of your savings, a 25 percent bonus sounds very alluring. Compared to other types of ISA, this one has a significantly higher annual rate. You must, however, confirm that you are at ease with the risks. In recent years, the regulations surrounding withdrawals have angered a growing number of savers.

According to the most recent annual HMRC LISA statistics, which were released on September 19, the number of unauthorised withdrawals in 2023 - 2024 increased by 31% over the previous year. A total of 75.3 million in withdrawal charges, or an average of 755 per person, were imposed on the 99,650 individuals who raided their LISAs.

It might have made more sense for those who had to take money out of their pot to cover urgent expenses to start by increasing their emergency fund, which would have been kept in an accessible savings account.

However, there are also a lot of encouraging LISA stories. After opening a Lifetime ISA, 81% of savers felt inspired to save more often, according to a survey conducted by Moneybox, the biggest provider of LISAs in the UK. Last year, Moneybox savers averaged 13,500 withdrawals, which included an average of 2,500 government bonuses.

The most important factor is still whether this savings product aligns with your financial objectives. Assessing your overall financial security and the anticipated cost of your first home could be a wise first step. A different savings vehicle might be a better choice for you if you fear that you will break the rules.

See More Assistance to Purchase.