Investment Advice

UK small-cap stocks have lagged badly for the past decade. That may be changing, making now a sensible time for careful investors to take a closer look.

UK small-cap stocks have lagged badly for the past decade. That may be changing, making now a sensible time for careful investors to take a closer look.
UK small-cap shares have a long record of beating larger companies. Research by Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh and Mike Staunton for UBS found that, from 1900 through the end of 2025, the smallest FTSE shares outperformed the broader market by about 2.5% a year on average.

Since 2010, the pattern has gone into reverse. Cassie Herlihy, portfolio manager of Henderson Smaller Companies Investment Trust, describes the period since then as something of a lost decade for UK small caps.

Small caps have trailed the broader market by roughly 5%-6% over the past ten years, although the exact gap depends on the index. Henry Ince, an equity strategy analyst at Morningstar, says the outlook may now be shifting: the wider economy shows signs of improvement, the government is encouraging institutions - particularly pension funds - to put more money into UK shares, and takeover activity is picking up.

Pension funds have also pulled back from UK equities. Around the turn of the millennium, British pension funds held roughly half of their assets in domestic shares, according to Georgina Brittain, manager of the JPMorgan UK Small Cap Growth & Income Trust. Today, that figure is below 5%, with much of the money redirected into global benchmarks. The scale of the withdrawal has pushed share prices down. Recent tax changes have added to the pressure, says Vishal Bhatia, senior fund manager at J O Hambro Capital Management's (JOHCM) UK Dynamic Fund. Shares on the Aim junior market were once largely exempt from inheritance tax. That exemption has gone.

Bhatia points to another possibility: short attention spans. Small-cap investing takes patience, yet investors now face an unprecedented stream of noise as social media delivers news instantly.

Early signs of recovery among UK smaller companies

Investors have had a frustrating few years, yet that weakness has pushed valuations to unusually low levels - both in absolute terms and compared with other markets. Roland Arnold, portfolio manager of the BlackRock Smaller Companies Trust, says prices now resemble those seen during periods of severe economic stress, despite the underlying conditions not warranting such pessimism. UK shares are already inexpensive by global standards; smaller companies trade at an additional discount.

Arnold says cheap valuations alone will not bring the sector back. Investors still need a reason to return, though no one can say exactly what that trigger will be. Prices have fallen so far that even a small rise in confidence might prompt them to reconsider the opportunities.

Herlihy says the wider UK economy may yet shift sentiment in the market. The year began with some cautious optimism, though the conflict in the Middle East damaged it; even so, the shock has likely postponed interest-rate cuts rather than ruled them out. Inflation has lost much of the grip it had just after Covid, leaving policymakers more room to support growth. Strong company and household balance sheets should provide another lift.

Bhatia agrees that if investors believe the current chancellor will keep spending fully funded and maintain fiscal discipline, long-term borrowing costs should eventually drop from their current elevated levels. A steadier gilt market could then give equity investors the confidence to commit capital for the long term.

Ince takes an even rosier view of the UK economy. Companies often used to gauge consumer spending - including Halfords, Young's and Greggs - have posted strong recent results and raised their expectations for the near term. Consumer confidence has reached a two-year high, while GDP growth, though modest, has avoided a serious slump. Small-cap stocks are also showing early signs of recovery, having outperformed larger companies over the past six months.

Reversing the flight from the UK

Helen Curtis, a partner at Devonshires, says institutional money returning to UK shares could give small caps a lift. Pension providers may have little room to resist. Under the Mansion House Accord, major providers have agreed to put 10% of workplace pension portfolios into productive assets by 2030, including at least 5% in UK investments. The government could press them harder, too. It might offer incentives such as lighter regulatory requirements and changes to listing rules; alternatively, it could raise the current voluntary target or turn the minimum allocation to UK shares into a legal requirement.

Herlihy thinks a formal mandate is unlikely soon. Even so, the growing discussion may prompt a few forward-looking pension funds to act before their peers, encouraging others to follow. Pension-fund managers are already questioning the belief that the US market will always outperform the UK. Increasingly, they see the UK as a relatively safe, fairly valued option for diversifying beyond the AI boom.

Herlihy says small caps do not need a sudden influx of institutional cash. Simply stopping the steady outflows could begin to support valuations, especially because relatively little buying can move the less liquid market. Brittain adds that pension funds hold so few UK shares that even a modest increase could give them a substantial lift.

M&A boom lifts small-cap fortunes

The clearest near-term boost for small caps may come from mergers and acquisitions (M&A). Low valuations have prompted a sharp rise in takeovers, with private-equity firms initially leading the charge. They were finding some of the best bargains of their lives, according to Brittain. Large companies have since joined in, buying rivals that look unusually cheap; the split now stands at roughly 60:40 between private equity and corporate buyers. Ince says some acquirers have offered eye-watering premiums. During the past three years, nine small-cap holdings in the JOHCM UK Dynamic Fund have been acquired, producing an average premium of about 67%. The highest was 169%, Bhatia says.

"Not everyone is pleased about it," Ince says. UK-focused fund managers and investment trusts have almost been forced to apologise to investors after selling companies they had intended to hold for the long term. Still, when an informed buyer pays a 40%, 50%, or even 80% premium, that says a great deal about how badly the market may have mispriced those businesses.

This year, transactions involving FTSE Small Cap constituents have reached roughly 3.9 billion - about 10% of the index's value - with another 2 billion in activity across Aim, according to Henry Norton of Arbuthnot Latham. Takeover premiums across the broader UK market have averaged about 45%, a clear sign that strategic and private-market buyers have paid well above public-market valuations. Companies are also responding to depressed share prices through buybacks, which are being used more often to support returns.

Where to find the best UK small cap bargains

Ince says UK small cap shares look attractive because valuations remain low while conditions are improving. That does not make every cheap stock a bargain, though: some are cheap for good reason and can trap unwary investors. Careful research matters. Arnold adds that the UK smaller-companies market is still under-researched, so investors willing to put in the legwork may find worthwhile opportunities.

Arnold says food production deserves close attention: people continue to need food even when the economy weakens. Infrastructure companies can offer similar reassurance, since many already hold orders stretching well into the future. Capital-goods firms may also gain as businesses raise spending after several years of restrained investment.

Curtis advises investors to examine small-cap companies in specialist healthcare, diagnostics, and medical technology, as well as firms providing the software, infrastructure, tools, and specialist services behind digital transformation. He also points to stocks that have fallen because investors fear AI-driven disruption. That risk is real but overstated; smaller companies are often quicker than larger rivals to respond to threats and act on change.

Take a bottom-up approach to UK small caps

Norton suggests looking past sector forecasts and examining individual small caps instead. Some have sound businesses but now trade at lower valuations simply because investors have withdrawn from the asset class, not because their operations have weakened. Firms that generate plenty of cash, maintain high margins, carry little debt and have management teams able to improve performance should have a better chance of growing even without a strong UK economy. Those qualities may also draw interest from potential buyers or merger partners.

Nikki Martin, senior portfolio manager of global equities at Sarasin & Partners, agrees that small-cap investors should assess each company on its own merits rather than start with the industry around it. A useful sign of overlooked value is a firm's dominance in a specialist overseas market: that often points to strong management, while the shares may still be valued using UK multiples despite the company earning international revenue.

Herlihy says the strongest small caps control their own fate. They have practical ways to spur growth, rein in costs and stay resilient even when the wider economy turns against them. The box below examines several of the most promising choices for investors today.

The best UK small cap investments to buy now

For a straightforward way to invest in this part of the market, consider an exchange-traded fund such as the iShares MSCI UK Small Cap UCITS ETF (LSE: CUKS). It follows the MSCI United Kingdom Small-Cap Net index. Its biggest holdings include Weir, St. James's Place and Games Workshop, each with a market capitalisation of about 5 billion. Some definitions would class those companies as mid caps. The fund still covers 193 holdings overall, with a median market capitalisation of roughly 1.3 billion. Its average price-to-earnings ratio is 14.5 times, while the total expense ratio is 0.53%.

For investors seeking a more hands-on small-cap fund, JPMorgan UK Small Cap Growth & Income trust (LSE: JUGI) is one option. Georgina Brittain and Katen Patel manage it, looking for fast-growing companies valued between 100 million and 4 billion while balancing value with momentum. The trust trades at an 8.7% discount to book value, or net assets. Over the past decade, its shares produced a 199.4% total return, versus 66.4% for the FTSE Small Cap excluding investment trusts, its benchmark. The ongoing charge is 0.75%, and the trust is widely expected to merge with Aberdeen UK Smaller Companies Growth Trust in the near future.

Keller Group (LSE: KLR) is the trust's largest holding, valued at 2.16 billion by market capitalisation. The company specialises in construction work, particularly building foundations. Brittain sees its role in the data-centre boom as a major source of future growth, and says the business is now hitting its stride. Sales rose by nearly half between 2020 and 2025, with further growth expected. Even so, the shares trade at just 11.8 times projected 2027 earnings and offer a 2.7% dividend yield.

Another small-cap construction company to watch is Sigmaroc (LSE: SRC). It extracts and processes building materials, including granite and limestone, before delivering them to customers. Hywel Franklin of Mirabaud Asset Management points to its entrepreneurial management team, which has built a business that generates substantial cash and remains attractively valued. Continental infrastructure-spending programmes could provide another source of growth as they take shape. Sigmaroc has a market capitalisation of 1.39 billion, while its shares trade at just ten times forecast 2027 earnings.

The Beauty Tech Group (LSE: TBTG) is a smaller company worth watching, with a market capitalisation of 547 million. Bhatia says it focuses on at-home beauty technology and has introduced several upgrades since floating on the stock market just over a year ago. Its CurrentBody Skin brand already holds a strong position in the premium market. The business generates plenty of cash and has net cash on its balance sheet, allowing it to continue buying back shares. A strong product pipeline adds to the appeal, with the new Series 3 LED mask expected to build momentum in the business.

Boku (LSE: BOKU) has a market capitalisation of 366 billion and helps technology companies accept local payment methods, mainly in emerging markets where traditional financial services remain out of reach for many people. Its customers include Meta, Amazon, Netflix and Google. Cassie Herlihy of Janus Henderson says the recently announced Stripe partnership stands out: it validates Boku's technology and infrastructure while potentially giving the company access to a much larger group of merchants. Sales more than doubled between 2020 and 2025, yet the shares trade at under 18 times expected 2027 earnings.